Rant for today*

A potential client sends out Terms of Reference requesting potential service providers to submit a quotation for an (5 maybe 10 person day) evaluation engagement. Note, they did not ask for a proposal, they asked for a quotation. Given the limited scope of the project, a quotation makes sense. So that is what I submit.

Then potential client reads through the proposals they received and *Horror* *shock* discovers that there isn’t enough information in the quotations to make a transparent decision. (Maybe there was a little problem with the Terms of Reference?) They then set up a meeting in which they expect potential service providers to present to a panel. “For the purposes of meeting with the potential evaluators and ensuring the selection process is fair and transparent”. (Have I mentioned that this is a small job?)

So I go and have a wonderful meeting with the potential client, but in the end do not get the job. My heart isn’t broken or anything. It would’ve been nice to get the job but… ah well, I think they looked for a content specialist rather than an evaluation specialist in the first place.

But hey, I am an evaluator, and evaluative thinking requires me to find out why I was not successful. So I write the “Thanks for the notification, we are disappointed, could you please tell us where our submission was weak… bla-di-blah” email. To which I don’t receive a response. I get my office manager to follow up and get a response of the kind: “We liked your presentation / Sorry we don’t have time to provide feedback / now please just leave us alone”.

What happened to the transparency and fairness thing? Am I unreasonable to think that a two line explanatory email is not much to ask after all of the trouble they put me through?

Ahem… The UK evaluation Society has some guidelines for persons when they commission evaluations at:

http://www.evaluation.org.uk/Pub_library/PRO2907%20-%20UKE.%20A5%20Guideline.pdf

Maybe more people should read that?

*Because this is my blog I get to complain here every now and again. I promise that this will not turn into those rant-upon-rant blogs, but I really need to get the following off my chest.